Elmira City, NY 14901 269 Baldwin Street

269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 1269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 2269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 3
20 more
269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 4269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 5269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 6269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 7269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 8269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 9269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 10269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 11269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 12269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 13269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 14269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 15269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 16269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 17269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 18269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 19269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 20269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 21269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 22269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 23269 Baldwin Street Elmira City, NY - Image 24
Presented By: Lindsay Hart with RE/MAX In Motion;
  • MLS# R1678237
  • 05/19/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • SQFT • 6,176

Home Details

Some buildings hold history in their walls. This one holds potential in every square foot. Standing three stories tall with a full basement on Baldwin Street in the heart of Elmira's downtown, 269 Baldwin is a commercial mixed-use building with the bones of something extraordinary — and the kind of scale that serious investors recognize immediately. Over 6,000 square feet of raw, untapped space, steps from the ILL Eagle Taphouse, and positioned squarely inside Elmira's $10 million New York State Downtown Revitalization Initiative target zone. The electricity is live to the building. The heat is not operational. It needs extensive rehab work. None of that is a secret — and none of it scares the right buyer. What the right buyer sees is what this building already is: structurally significant, mixed-use zoned, and sitting at the intersection of a city actively being rebuilt. Exterior wall repair was professionally completed by Streeter Associates in 2022 — documentation included. That's a seller who maintained what mattered. The building's mixed commercial and residential zoning opens the door to virtually any vision — ground-floor retail or restaurant, upper-floor residential units, professional office, hospitality concepts, or a full adaptive reuse that capitalizes on Elmira's growing demand for walkable downtown housing. State and federal historic tax credit programs have financed multiple nearby projects. The incentive infrastructure is already in place. Downtown Elmira is not a rumor. It is a movement. The DRI investment, the I-86 Innovation Corridor, the expansion of healthcare and higher education nearby — This is the momentum that turns 269 Baldwin into a deal that makes sense right now, not five years from now. The glory is still in here. Bring the capital. Bring the vision.
Presented By: Lindsay Hart with RE/MAX In Motion;

Interior Features for 269 Baldwin Street

Bathrooms

Main Level Bathrooms0
Total Baths

Other Interior Features

BasementFull
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Fireplace Y/NNo
FlooringHardwood, Linoleum, Plywood, Varies, Vinyl
Heating Y/NNo
Total Fireplaces
Total Stories4

General for 269 Baldwin Street

CityElmira City
Construction MaterialsBrick, Block, Frame
CountyChemung
Elementary School DistrictElmira
HeatingElectric, Gas, None
High School DistrictElmira
Lease Considered Y/NNo
Lot Size Square Feet2403.0
Lot Size UnitsAcres
MLS AreaElmira-City-070400
Middle/Junior School DistrictElmira
Number Of Units Total
PossessionCloseOfEscrow, Closing
Possible UseOffice, Other, Retail, ServiceBusiness, Service, SpecialUse
Property ConditionResale
Property Sub Type AdditionalMixedUse, Commercial
Property SubtypeMixedUse
Property TypeCommercialSale
RoofRolledHotMop, Shingle
School DistrictElmira
SewerPublicSewer
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Stories Count4
Tax Annual Amount56957.0
Tax Assessed Value34000
Tax Lot18
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount55700.0
TownshipNot Applicable
UtilitiesElectricityConnected, SewerConnected, WaterConnected
Year Built1954
Year Built DetailsExisting
ZoningComm
Zoning DescriptionCommercial

Exterior for 269 Baldwin Street

Building Area Total6176.0
InclusionsLand and Building
Lot Dimensions24X100
Lot FeaturesRectangular, RectangularLot
Lot Size Acres0.0552
Lot Size Area0.0552
Number of Buildings1
Parking FeaturesOnSite
Total Parking10.0
Water SourcePublic
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Mark Siwiec

CEO
Price $40,000
MLS#R1678237
List Date 05/19/2026
Property Type Commercial
Phone
Request Tour
Request Info

Similar Properties to 269 Baldwin Street