Castile, NY 14427 21 South Main Street

OPEN HOUSE Sun, Apr 26 2026 01:00 PM - 03:00 PM
21 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 121 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 221 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3
44 more
21 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 421 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 521 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 621 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 721 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 821 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 921 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1021 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1121 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1221 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1321 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1421 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1521 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1621 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1721 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1821 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 1921 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2021 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2121 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2221 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2321 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2421 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2521 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2621 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2721 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2821 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 2921 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3021 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3121 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3221 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3321 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3421 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3521 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3621 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3721 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3821 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 3921 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4021 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4121 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4221 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4321 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4421 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4521 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4621 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 4721 South Main Street Castile, NY - Image 48
Presented By: Matthew Sharman with Real Broker NY LLC;
  • MLS# R1674936
  • 04/22/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 2
  • Full/Half Baths • 1 / 1
  • SQFT • 1,529

Home Details

What if the one you almost skipped is the one that completely flips your expectations? From the outside, you see a typical village home. You’ve seen this before. You almost keep scrolling. Then you look inside… and it’s a completely different story. Nothing is generic. The vibe is funky, fun, and unapologetically unique. Every space feels intentional. Creative. Open. You’ve got over 1,500 square feet and almost half an acre, which already puts you in a different category. Then you realize the backyard isn’t just “nice”… it’s an actual escape. A stream running through it & a level of privacy you don’t expect in the village. Quiet. Peaceful. Yours. Then you hit the bathroom… and it doesn’t match what you thought this house was going to be. In the best way. Heated floors. Sharp tile work. A level of finish that catches you off guard. Walk upstairs and you’ve got smart functionality with a half bath exactly where you want it. Compact bedrooms that feel airy instead of cramped. No shortage of sunlight here- a massive wraparound deck, or sitting in the panoramic enclosed porch (with a skylight), and it just feels different. And the part that usually comes back to bite you later? Already handled. The mechanicals are only a couple years old. Nothing looming. Nothing waiting to surprise you. It’s even set up with an EV charger. You’ve also got off-street parking and a 10x20 outbuilding that gives you flexibility most village homes just don’t have. This isn’t the safe, predictable choice. This is the one you remember. Step inside and decide if “different” is exactly what you’ve been looking for. In the spirit of doing things differently… NO delayed negotiations.
Presented By: Matthew Sharman with Real Broker NY LLC;

Interior Features for 21 South Main Street

Bedrooms

Main Level Bedrooms0
Total Bedrooms2

Bathrooms

Half Baths1
Main Level Bathrooms1
Total Baths2

Other Interior Features

Air Conditioning Y/NYes
BasementFull
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Fireplace Y/NNo
FlooringHardwood, Tile, Varies
Furnished Y/NFurnished
Heating Y/NYes
Interior AmenitiesFurnished, SeparateFormalLivingRoom, KitchenIsland, Storage, Skylights, NaturalWoodwork
Laundry FeaturesInBasement
Total Fireplaces
Total Stories2
Window FeaturesSkylights

General for 21 South Main Street

AppliancesDryer, Dishwasher, ElectricOven, ElectricRange, ElectricWaterHeater, Microwave, Washer
Architectural StyleHistoricAntique
CityCastile
Construction MaterialsWoodSiding
CoolingDuctless
CountyWyoming
ElectricCircuitBreakers
Elementary School DistrictLetchworth
Full Baths1
Garage Spaces0.0
Garage Y/NNo
HeatingDuctless, Electric, Gas, ForcedAir
High School DistrictLetchworth
LevelsTwo
Lot Size Square Feet18180.0
Lot Size UnitsAcres
MLS AreaCastile-Village-562601
Middle/Junior School DistrictLetchworth
Number Of Units Total
Other StructuresSheds, Storage
Patio/Porch FeaturesDeck
PossessionCloseOfEscrow
Property ConditionResale
Property SubtypeSingleFamilyResidence
Property TypeResidential
RoofAsphalt
School DistrictLetchworth
Senior Community Y/NNo
SewerConnected
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Stories Count2
Subdivision NameCottringer
Tax Annual Amount5335.0
Tax Assessed Value65000
Tax Lot21
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount0.0
Total Rooms8
TownshipCastile-Village
UtilitiesElectricityConnected, HighSpeedInternetAvailable, SewerConnected, WaterConnected
Year Built1875
Year Built DetailsExisting

Exterior for 21 South Main Street

Building Area Total1529.0
Exterior AmenitiesDeck, EnclosedPorch, Fence, GravelDriveway, Porch, PrivateYard, SeeRemarks
FencingPartial
Foundation DetailsBlock, Stone
Lot Dimensions90X202
Lot FeaturesCornerLot, Rectangular, RectangularLot
Lot Size Acres0.4174
Lot Size Area0.4174
Parking FeaturesElectricVehicleChargingStations, NoGarage
Road Frontage TypeMainThoroughfare
Water SourceConnected, Public
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Mark Siwiec

CEO
Price $169,100
MLS#R1674936
List Date 04/22/2026
Property Type Single Family
Phone
Request Tour
Request Info

Similar Properties to 21 South Main Street