Potter, NY 14544 52 Gilbert Street

52 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 152 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 252 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 3
22 more
52 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 452 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 552 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 652 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 752 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 852 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 952 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1052 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1152 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1252 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1352 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1452 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1552 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1652 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1752 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1852 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 1952 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 2052 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 2152 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 2252 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 2352 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 2452 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 2552 Gilbert Street Potter, NY - Image 26
Presented By: Cathy J. Shelanskey with Keller Williams Realty Gateway;
  • MLS# R1673809
  • 04/15/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 3
  • Baths • 1
  • SQFT • 2,256
  • Garage • 1

Home Details

Classic colonial offering a blend of historic charm with modern potential. Spanning 2,256 square feet on 0.43-acre lot, this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home makes a striking first impression with its crisp white siding, vibrant green shutters. Inside, you’ll find open living space and rich hardwood flooring that flows through the main level. The large, light-filled kitchen features a full suite of stainless steel appliances, ample wood cabinetry, and a sunny window overlooking the grounds. The level yard, garage and horseshoe driveway offer space for any outdoor toys you may want to keep around, being situated between Canandaigua and Seneca Lakes. You are perfectly positioned to enjoy the best of the Finger Lakes region, from the renowned breweries and wineries along the nearby wine trails to highly-rated local restaurants. For outdoor enthusiasts, the area offers exceptional hiking and proximity to the water, providing a quiet, rural lifestyle without sacrificing access to regional attractions. With its character-filled interior and expansive yard, this property offers a rare opportunity to enjoy a historic silhouette with plenty of room to grow. Some photos have been virtually staged. Pool does NOT convey. Delayed negotiations until 4/20 at 12pm.
Presented By: Cathy J. Shelanskey with Keller Williams Realty Gateway;

Interior Features for 52 Gilbert Street

Bedrooms

Main Level Bedrooms0
Total Bedrooms3

Bathrooms

Half Baths0
Main Level Bathrooms
Total Baths1

Other Interior Features

BasementFull
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Fireplace Y/NNo
FlooringHardwood, Varies, Vinyl
Heating Y/NYes
Interior AmenitiesCeilingFans, SeparateFormalDiningRoom, SeparateFormalLivingRoom, PullDownAtticStairs
Total Fireplaces
Total Stories2

General for 52 Gilbert Street

AppliancesDishwasher, ElectricOven, ElectricRange, GasWaterHeater, Microwave, Refrigerator
Architectural StyleColonial
Attached Garage Yes
CityPotter
Construction MaterialsWoodSiding, PexPlumbing
CountyYates
DirectionsHead east on 20&5 from Canandaigua, then turn right onto NY-364 S (E Lake Rd) and follow it for about 8 miles. Turn left onto County Rd 1 and continue onto Gilbert St into Rushville. 52 Gilbert St wil
ElectricCircuitBreakers
Elementary School DistrictMarcus Whitman
Full Baths1
Garage Spaces1.0
Garage Y/NYes
HeatingGas, ForcedAir
High School DistrictMarcus Whitman
LevelsTwo
Lot Size Square Feet18620.0
Lot Size UnitsAcres
MLS AreaRushville Village-573201
Middle/Junior School DistrictMarcus Whitman
Number Of Units Total
Patio/Porch FeaturesOpen, Porch
PossessionCloseOfEscrow
Property ConditionResale
Property SubtypeSingleFamilyResidence
Property TypeResidential
RoofAsphalt, Shingle
School DistrictMarcus Whitman
Senior Community Y/NNo
SewerConnected
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Stories Count2
Tax Annual Amount5238.0
Tax Assessed Value189000
Tax Lot13
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount0.0
Total Rooms8
TownshipRushville-Village
UtilitiesSewerConnected, WaterConnected
Year Built1904
Year Built DetailsExisting

Exterior for 52 Gilbert Street

Building Area Total2256.0
Exterior AmenitiesGravelDriveway
Foundation DetailsStone
Lot Dimensions98X190
Lot FeaturesRectangular, RectangularLot, ResidentialLot
Lot Size Acres0.4275
Lot Size Area0.4275
Parking FeaturesAttached, Garage
Road Frontage TypeCityStreet
Water SourceConnected, Public
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Mark Siwiec

CEO
Price $199,900
MLS#R1673809
List Date 04/15/2026
Property Type Single Family
Phone
Request Tour
Request Info

Similar Properties to 52 Gilbert Street